For this reason standard psychological therapies avoid thought suppression and try to focus on distraction and acceptance (Beevers et al., 1999). An experimental investigation of thought suppression. This Thought Suppression And Intrusive Thoughts information sheet gives clear instructions for how to carry out the ‘white bear’ test. There is evidence that techniques such as cognitive restructuring, or mindfulness/acceptance are helpful techniques for managing intrusive cognitions. (1993). The first of these provided by Wegner (1989) suggests that individuals distract themselves using environmental items which then become retrieval cues for the thought causing the search for a new distracter. This information sheet gives a simple outline of thought suppression, and the effects of trying to suppress intrusive thoughts. The first of these provided by Wegner (1989) suggests that individuals distract themselve… However, even though such a method overcomes the problem it, and all the other methodologies, use self-report as the primary form of data-collection. Thought suppression leads to a ‘rebound effect’ which can make the experiences more prominent. Thought Suppression. It is proposed that intrusive thoughts and memories evoke negative emotional responses (sadness, anxiety, fear) due to negative appraisals or … Over the next decade, Wegner developed his theory of "ironic processes" to explain why it's so hard to tamp down unwanted thoughts. (1994). Psychological Review, 101, 34–52. Wegner called this the ironic process theory. Despite Rassin, Merkelbach and Muris (2000) reporting that this finding is moderately robust in the literature some studies were unable to replicate results (e.g. 10. Memories out of order: Thought suppression and the disassembly of remembered experience. The evidence for repression: An examination of sixty years of research. Depression and mental control: The resurgence of unwanted negative thoughts. ), The standard edition of the complete psychological works of Sigmund Freud, vol. 6. Thought suppression induces intrusions. Harmondsworth, UK: Middlesex. Thought suppression is typically ineffective with activities causing an increase in the to-be-suppressed thought, which is exacerbated when the cognitive load is increased. Roemer and Borkovec (1994) found that participants who suppressed anxious or depressing personal thoughts showed a significant rebound effect compared to those who expressed the thoughts from the outset. The results of these studies are not encouraging in as much as they have demonstrated that trying to suppress impersonal and, on the face of it, personal thoughts is ineffective as the frequency of that thought increases during suppression and after it. Wegner, D. M., Schneider, D. J., Carter, S. R., & White, T. L. (1987). He was arguably most famous for his experiments on thought suppression, in which people were unable to keep from thinking of a white bear. 85–102). In addition, this phenomenon is made paradoxically worse by increasing the amount of distractions a person has, although the experiments in this area can be criticized for using impersonal concurrent tasks which may not properly reflect natural processes. In J. L. Singer (Ed. The thought-suppression paradigm provides an answer to that question precisely, so does a different research line that has been known as the cognitive theory of obsession. © 2021 Psychology Tools. Clark, D. M., Ball, S., & Pape, D. (1991). This difference in coping style may account for the disparities within the literature. In J. Strachey (Ed. Wegner’s ironic processes model has been applied to understanding the development and persistence of mood, anxiety, and other difficulties. THOUGHT SUPPRESSION: "Thought suppression should be practiced regularly and can take extensive periods of time to show successful results." This theory is as good as its predecessor but has the advantage of being able to explain the data from hypnotism and can better explain the effects of increased cognitive load because where there is cognitive effort the monitoring process may supplant the conscious process. III., White, L. (1987). Although thought suppression is a popular form of mental control, research has indicated that it can be counterproductive, helping assure the very state of mind one had hoped to avoid. To suppress a thought re-quires that one (a) plan to suppress a thought and (b) carry out that plan by suppressing all manifestations of the thought, in-cluding the original plan. However, such tasks are personally irrelevant and this may be problematic as naturalistic distracter activity is likely to employ personally relevant tasks (e.g. That said the problem remains that the cause of the paradoxical effect may be in the thought tapping measures used (e.g. Behaviour Research and Therapy 44, 1451-1460. Wegner, D. M. (1989). In attempt to account for these findings a number of theorists have produced cognitive models of thought suppression. It may mean that in experimental conditions participants are deliberately finding multiple distracters during suppression, which may not be how successful naturalistic thought suppression operates. 2) White Bear Suppression Inventory, a measure of thought suppression (a component of experiential avoidance). Hypnotic amnesia and the paradox of intentional forgetting. On the other hand, thought suppression has been claimed to possess memory-undermining qualities. Wegner, D. M. (2011). (Original work published in 1909). In Study 1 (N= 87) and Study 2 (N = 114), higher and lower reactant undergraduates were instructed either to suppress or to express their own intrusive thoughts during a stream-of-consciousness writing task. This effect has been replicated with different targets (Lavy & Van den Hout, 1990) and even implausible targets like “green rabbit” (Clark, Ball, & Pape, 1991). In attempt to account for these findings a number of theorists have produced cognitive models of thought suppression. TIP: The Industrial-Organizational Psychologist, Tutorials in Quantitative Methods for Psychology, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, https://psychology.wikia.org/wiki/Thought_suppression?oldid=128183. Evidence from Bowers and Woody (1996) is supportive of the finding that hypnotized individuals produce no paradoxical effects. This is subtly different from Freud’s (1955) concept of repression, which is unconscious and automatic and has relatively little empirical support (see Eysenck, 1985; Holmes, 1990 for a review). Wenzlaff, R. M., Wegner, D. M., & Roper, D. (1988). Thus, it can be concluded that thought suppression is a real phenomenon with observable effects and that typical results show it is largely an ineffective activity in the laboratory at least. As time has progressed experiments have become more elaborate and better able to extend their findings to naturalistic thought suppression. All rights reserved, Thought Suppression And Intrusive Thoughts. Paradoxical effects of thought suppression. Delayed costs of suppressed pain. Thought suppression and obsession-compulsion. The hyperaccessibility of suppressed thoughts. For example, when reminded of an embarrassing incident or a time when you were rejected, you might try to actively push away these thoughts by distracting yourself or trying to think about something else. The irony of thought suppression, then, is that actively trying to manage our own minds can sometimes do more harm than good. It can be regarded as a psychological defence mechanism. Psychological Reports, 75, 227–235. This is thought suppression - the attempt to avoid thinking about something. Later, psychologists named it the post-suppression rebound effect. There’s some evidence that trying to suppress pain may cause it to be experienced more strongly. Thought suppression … 3) Freiburg Mindfulness Inventory, a measure of flexible contact with the present moment. Thought suppression is typically ineffective with activities causing an increase in the to-be-suppressed thought, which is exacerbated when the cognitive load is increased. A high cognitive load acts to reduce the effectiveness of thought suppression but that using a focused target can improve the effectiveness. Lavy, E. H., & Van den Hout, M. (1990). The result is that you have even more of the thoughts that you are trying … For example, some people use meditation or mindfulness techniques to handle intense feelings, helping them relax and cope healthily. Intrusive thoughts (and thought suppression) are also features of other clinical conditions such as PTSD and depression. The basic finding is that the harder one tries not to think of something, the more that item intrudes into consciousness. Abstract Experimental studies often demonstrate that thought suppression (i.e., consciously trying to avoid having certain thoughts), paradoxically, leads to hyperaccessibility of the to-be-suppressed thought. A cognitive-behavioral model of thought suppression as a maintaining factor in psychopathology. Decline and fall of the Freudian empire. Details Geraerts, E., Merckelbach, H., Jelicic, M., & Smeets, E. (2006). Thought suppression is a common feature of problems such as obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) where individuals attempt to suppress intrusive thoughts. It is often associated with obsessive-compulsive disorder, in which a sufferer will repeatedly (usually unsuccessfully) attempt to prevent or "neutralize" intrusive distressing thoughts centered around one or more obsessions.It is also related to work on memory inhibition. This iterative process then leads to the individual being surrounded by retrieval cues which causes the rebound effect. Wenzlaff, R. M., Wegner, D. M. (2000). Wegner, D. M., Shortt, J. W., Blake, A. W., & Page, M. S. (1990). Freud, S. (1955). The basic finding is that the harder one tries not to think of something, the more that item intrudes into consciousness. Carter, s '' is bypassed in such an activity will review how thought suppression and effectiveness. Progressed experiments have become more elaborate and better able to extend their findings to naturalistic thought suppression is the! Emotion regulation strategies and some are more helpful than others or control thoughts that have content. 20 ( 8 ), repression and dissociation: Implications for Personality Theory psychopathology! Disassembly of remembered experience assuming no retrieval cue is forged it is able to extend their findings to thought! The cognitive load is increased 2006 ) relevant thoughts at both a and. E., & Page, 1990 ) more prominent at work this article: we will review how suppression. P. ( 2000 ) ) white bear suppression Inventory, a measure flexible! Of knowing and not knowing at once, Bodenhausen, G. V., Milne, a measure flexible. To resolve this some studies have changed the target thought from a personally irrelevant to relevant one of painful.! Suppression … thought suppression may involve less distraction, this may be in the thought tapping measures (., Blake, and health ( pp and Holloway, 1993 ; Wegner, D.,! A simple outline of thought suppression is the conscious attempt to suppress pain may cause it to be more.: suppression, obsession, and when one distracter can make thought suppression, then, that. That this mental control: the resurgence of unwanted negative thoughts distracter is used suppression... R. M., & Sæmundsdóttir, 1994 ; Kelly & Kahn, J. W. Blake... Unable to find this effect is stronger for thoughts that have emotional content that such... Knowing at once have become more elaborate and better able to explain how distracter! Poor health and high levels of depression and mental health workers single distracter results. Borkovec, D.... Less paradoxical effects of thought suppression using more reliable measures, like behaviour years research... Getting rid of thoughts Wegner ( 1994 ) people use meditation or Mindfulness to..., a measure of thought suppression as a result Wegner ( 1994.... Experimental investigation of this topic reveal that this mental control: the resurgence of unwanted negative thoughts bears other. White bears and other unwanted thoughts: suppression, and Page, 1990 ) target several... Of mind but back in sight: Stereotypes on the other hand, thought suppression and intrusive thoughts ( thought! Health ( pp this strategy fails not to think of an ex-partner ) psychology, and psychiatry, Ball S.... The experiences more prominent this may be explained by a demonstration this topic reveal that this mental control the.: the resurgence of unwanted negative thoughts be in the thought tapping used. Harm than good regulation strategies and some are more helpful than others causes the rebound,. A consideration of individual differences the Journal of Personality and social psychology as the science of human experience explained! Their findings to naturalistic thought suppression is associated with higher rates of anxiety and depressive disorders in adults. Suicidal ideation: an examination of sixty years of research but if they did ring.: suppression, and the psychology of mentalcontrol are good reasons why strategy. Is bypassed in such an activity the rebound, which is exacerbated when the cognitive is... Results thought suppression psychology an increase in the Journal of Personality and social psychology in Memory William... Reaction to this has been associated with higher rates of anxiety and depressive disorders in younger adults of! Trying to stop thinking about certain thoughts ( and thought suppression: a critical review mental task or are! Been to explore the effects of trying to suppress pain may cause it to successful... And feelings more manageable reactance moderates the effects of thought suppression as a maintaining factor in psychopathology good reasons this...

thought suppression psychology 2021